Earliest Evidence of Ship Repair on City Island in the Town of Pelham

Archive of the Historic Pelham Web Site.
Home Page of the Historic Pelham Blog.
Order a Copy of "The Haunted History of Pelham, New York"
Order a Copy of "Thomas Pell and the Legend of the Pell Treaty Oak."

City Island, part of Pelham for nearly 250 years until its annexation by New York City in 1895, is strategically located near the "entrance" to Long Island Sound from the East River and New York Harbor.  Indeed, it is the first substantial island in the Sound North of Throggs Neck on the mainland and Kings Point on Long Island, an area where many believe the so-called "East River" becomes Long Island Sound.  

As long ago as 1651, Dutch settler Adriaen Van der Donck recognized the strategic importance of the lands and islands in this area when he wrote:  "land fortifies itself remarkably and also lends itself naturally to fortification at Sandy Hook, The Narrows, Hell Gate, or at other bays and entrances so as to make it, humanly speaking, impregnable."  Van der Donck, Adriaen, A Description of New Netherland, pp. 132-33 (Lincoln, NE and London:  University of Nebraska Press, 2008) (Edited by Charles T. Gehring and William A. Starna; Translated by Diederik Willem Goedhuys).  

 

Image from Google Maps Showing City Island and Long Island

Sound (in Upper Right) Relative to the East River at Bottom.

NOTE:  Click on Image to Enlarge.

Given its location, mariners traveling up and down the northeast coast of America have sailed past today's City Island since at least the earliest years of the 17th century.  Thus, it should come as no surprise that the sloping, sandy shores of City Island, adjacent to deep water and even somewhat protected by nearby Hart Island, has been used for ship repair and shipbuilding for at least nearly two centuries.  Indeed, even before the Revolutionary War, people such as Benjamin Palmer recognized that the island known today as City Island was ideally situated to attract and service vessels sailing to and from nearby New York City. In fact, Palmer devised a grandiose plan to rename the island (then known as Minneford Island) as "City Island" and to develop it as a deep water harbor town intended to rival, and compete with, New York City's port of New York Harbor.  That plan, of course, ended ignominiously with the onset of the Revolutionary War.

I have written before about the history of shipbuilding on City Island.  See, e.g.:  Fri., Jun. 16, 2017:  Origins of Ship Repair and Shipbuilding on City Island in the Town of Pelham.  Today's Historic Pelham Blog article documents a brief newspaper reference demonstrating that City Island was used as an impromptu ship repair site in 1821.

In 1821, the Town of Pelham was virtually unpopulated.  The Town tax assessment roll for 1821 shows only 31 taxpayers in the entire town.  See Tue., Apr. 05, 2005:  1821 Tax Assessment Roll of the Town of Pelham.  According to the Pelham School Commissioners' Report to the Superintendent of Common Schools of the State of New York for the year 1821, there were 65 school age children in Pelham, although only 35 of these children attended school during the year previous to the report.  See Wed., Nov. 12, 2014:  September 1821 Report from Pelham School Commissioners to the Superintendent of Common Schools of the State of New York. 

At about this time, City Island likewise was nearly unpopulated.  As of 1818, most of the island was owned by Nicholas Haight and Joshua Huested.  On January 1, 1819, however, Nicholas Haight and his wife, Mary, sold to George Washington Horton 42 acres on the lower (southern) portion of City Island.  Nevertheless, even as early as 1821, the waters around City Island in the Town of Pelham were quite busy.  For example, I have written before about the steamship Robert Fulton and its anchorage at City Island in 1821.  See Mon., Oct. 17, 2016:  The Famed Pioneer Steamship Robert Fulton Anchored at City Island During an Excursion in 1821.

There are many news accounts that reflect maritime activity in the waters near City Island at the time.  For example, one sad account published on May 3, 1821, reported:

"Accident. -- A small boat in crossing from City Island to Throgg's Neck, on Sunday last, was filled by getting in the trough of the sea.  Mr. Pearson, head carpenter of the buildings erecting by Elbert Anderson, Esq. and a lad about 18 years old, jumped overboard and were drowned.  --  Another lad about 13 years old, stuck to the boat and was saved."

Source:  Accident, The National Gazette and Literary Register [Philadelphia, PA], May 3, 1821, Vol. 1, No. 156, p. 2, col. 3 (NOTE:  Paid subscription required to access via this link).

A very brief report published earlier the same year is evidence that City Island was used as a site for impromptu ship repairs as early as 1821.  The report indicates that on February 13, 1821, a sloop from Newport named Agent sprang a leak and was hauled ashore at City Island for repairs.  The entire report reads:  "The sloop Agent, Blisen, from Newport, hauled ashore yesterday at City island, to stop a leak." Source:  MARINE LIST, The New-York Evening Post, Feb. 14, 1821, No. 5818, p. 3, col. 1. 

Archive of the Historic Pelham Web Site.
Home Page of the Historic Pelham Blog.
Order a Copy of "The Haunted History of Pelham, New York"
Order a Copy of "Thomas Pell and the Legend of the Pell Treaty Oak."