Historic Pelham

Presenting the rich history of Pelham, NY in Westchester County: current historical research, descriptions of how to research Pelham history online and genealogy discussions of Pelham families.

Wednesday, February 14, 2018

More on a Magical Long Distance Proposal Made to a Pelham Manor Belle in 1895


Happy Saint Valentine's Day Dear Pelham.

Saint Valentine's Day in 1895 was a particularly memorable one for two young people who met on that date in the home of a local resident. The story of their meeting, their brief long-distance courtship, and their subsequent marriage, brings warmth to the heart.  The story is that of beau George B. Gaston of Indianapolis and Ethel Mary Bishop, an English girl who lived temporarily in Pelham Manor in 1895.  The story of their engagement made the pair famous throughout the United States and has been the subject of an earlier Historic Pelham article.  See Fri., Feb. 13, 2015:  A Magical Valentine's Day in Pelham Manor in 1895.

In 1895, George B Gaston was a bashful 35-year-old confirmed bachelor who lived in Indianapolis, Indiana. In his early youth, Gaston was involved in an electrical business managed by Thomas Alva Edison and Edison's then-close friend, Ezra Torrence Gilliland of Pelham Manor. During that time, Ezra Gilliland grew fond not only of young Gaston, but also two of his sisters.  Fate, however, led George Gaston to Indianapolis where he served as the successful Secretary and Treasurer of the Indianapolis Transfer Company.

Ezra and Lillian Gilliland were particularly fond of the young bachelor whose business frequently brought him to New York City.  According to some accounts, George Gaston often stayed with or visited the Gilliland family in Pelham Manor during his business trips to New York City.  Other accounts suggest he kept putting such visits off because the Gilliland home was always filled with guests and Gaston was rather shy.

Ezra T. Gilliland was a very successful and affluent inventor in his own right and an associate of Thomas Edison who visited Gilliland's laboratory and lovely home in Pelham Manor on occasion.  Clearly the Gilliland home in Pelham Manor often was filled with guests.  See:

Tue., Aug. 04, 2015:  Ezra T. Gilliland, The Inventor of the Telephone Switchboard and Friend of Thomas Edison, Was a Pelham Manor Resident.

Tue., May 02, 2017:  More on Ezra T. Gilliland of Pelham Manor, Inventor of the Telephone Switchboard and Friend of Thomas Edison.

Thu., Aug. 13, 2015:  Lillian Johnson Gilliland's Memories of Thomas Edison and 19th Century Life in Pelham Manor.

As fate would have it, one of the guests in the Gilliland home in February, 1895 was a beautiful 22-year-old English woman named Ethel Mary Bishop, a daughter of Hon. James Draper Bishop of London.  By all accounts Miss Bishop was a beautiful young belle with dark hair and dark eyes with a lovely English accent that reportedly captivated young men throughout Pelham during her business.  

In February, 1895, Gaston's business on behalf of the Indianapolis Transfer Company called him to New York City. While he was there, Ezra T. Gilliland invited him to visit the Gilliland home in Pelham Manor. Gaston put off the invitation until the day before his scheduled return to Indianapolis. On the appointed day, February 14, 1895, he traveled to the Gililland home where he planned to visit for a few hours. Instead, he stayed there for two weeks.

In early 1895, George Gaston's two sisters visited the Gilliland home and met Ethel Mary Bishop.  The two young women seem to have been as captivated with the young English woman as many others in Pelham.  They began writing letters to their brother George extolling the virtues of the charming Miss Bishop.  According to one account:

"From those letters Gaston had learned that Miss Bishop had been born in Shanghai, while her father was serving the English government there as Consul.  As a child she had lived in Africa, her gather having been transferred to one of the South African States.  Later she had been sent to a convent in Paris whence she went to Heidelberg, and there she took a degree in music.  Then she went to London to continue her studies in music and the classics."

In early February, 1895, George Gaston had another business trip to New York City.  Upon his arrival, Ezra Gilliland extended his customary invitation to the young man to stay with his family at his Pelham Manor home.  Gaston put off the visit until Valentine's Day -- the day before he was scheduled to return to Indianapolis.

On Valentine's Day, 123 years ago today, Gaston visited the Gilliland home and met Ethel Mary Bishop.  The following day, he could not bring himself to return to Indianapolis.  Instead, he remained in the Gilliland home for two weeks before he returned to his home.  He was more than captivated with the young English girl.  He was in love.

The New York City newspaper The Sun later published an amusing account of how Gaston eventually proposed to the young girl.  Because the proposal was made over the relatively new-fangled telephone from "800 miles away," The Sun's account was picked up and reproduced in newspapers large and small throughout the United States making the young couple famous.  According to that account:

"When he returned to Indianapolis he wasn't able to do much business.  All he could think about was the English girl on the shore of Long Island Sound.  Two weeks went by and one morning while he was sitting in his office a letter came from one of his sisters.  It was largely filled with a description of a german she had danced a few nights before, and told how all the men had simply gone daft about Miss Bishop.  Gaston thought for a moment, and then rushed to the telephone, looked up the number of Gilliland's house telephone in the long-distance telephone book, and asked to be connected.  Pretty soon he heard a feminine voice at the other end of the line call, 'Hello!'

'Hello!  Who is that?' answered Gaston.  'Who?  Oh!  Miss Bishop?  Well, this is Mr. Gaston Miss Bishop.  Where am I?  In Indianapolis.  Yes, in Indianapolis.  I thought I'd call you up to -- to ask how my sisters are.  You'll call one of them and let her speak for herself?  Oh, never mind, I said 'never mind.'  N-e-v-e-r-never.  No, not mine; mind -- m-i-n-d.  Hello!  How are you?  Just going to the city?  Theatre party to-night?  Oh, not going in till the 4 o'clock train?  Wish I were going with you.  I said I wish I were going with you.  I don't know whether my sisters would like to have me or not.  I just wanted to go with you.  Don't be foolish?  Hello!  What did you say?  Hello!  Hello!  Say, Central!  Don't cut me off!  I'm not through talking yet.  Gone at the other end?  Well, ring up again.'

As Mr. Gaston said last night, he was bound to say something then or die in the attempt.  After waiting some time, he got the Gilliland house again and began talking with Miss Bishop.

'I beat about the bush for a long time,' he said, 'and then I came out with the question.  She evidently couldn't understand me, for this was the answer I got:

'Come a little nearer Mr. Gaston.  I can't hear you.'

'Then I moved about one inch nearer to her in that eight hundred miles and asked the question over again.  This time it was perfectly understood.  I was told that I might not be sure of myself, that I had better wait for a while, and some more things like that.  I said I had lived to be 35 years old, and I guessed I knew my own mind.  Finally I was told that she would give me an answer when she called me up in two weeks.'

That was on Feb. 28.  Two weeks after that Miss Bishop was in Brooklyn one day and stepped into the office of Mr. Gilliland.  She called up Mr. Gaston.

'Hello!  Is that you Mr. Gaston?  This is Miss Bishop.  Knew the voice, did you?  Your memory for sound is excellent.  I wonder if it is as good for other things.  One other thing?  What's that?  Oh, my answer?  Was I to give you an answer about anything?  Hello!  What's that?  I know very well I was?  Yes I guess I do.  Two weeks have seemed like two years?  You say that very nicely -- over the telephone.  Well, are you sure you knew what you were talking about?  Positive?  And you don't think you'll regret it some time?  Sure?  Well, then, if you want yes, here it is.  What's that?  Hello!  What did you say?  Oh!  Well, you can't have that over the telephone.  You must come for that yourself.  Good-by, George.'

It wasn't long before he came for what he couldn't get over the telephone, and the arrangements for the wedding were made."

Yes, indeed.  The couple married.  Their engagement story represents even to this day a lovely Pelham Valentine's Day story.












*          *          *          *          *

"PROPOSED BY TELEPHONE.
-----
GOT A 'YES,' TOO, OVER RIGHT HUNDRED MILES OF WIRE.
-----
One End Each of Two Conversations Between George B. Gaston in Indianapolis and Ethel Mary Bishop Right Here -- Married at Pelham Manor Last Tuesday.

A man deserved to win a wife who has the nerve to call up a girl, eight hundred miles away, over the telephone and ask her to marry him.  That is the way Miss Ethel Mary Bishop, the only daughter of the Hon. James Draper Bishop of London, became engaged to George B. Gaston of Indianapolis.  They were married last Tuesday night at the residence of Ezra T. Gilliland at Pelham Manor.

Mr. Gaston is the son of a retired physician and is the Secretary and Treasurer of the Indianapolis Transfer Company.  For several years he was associated in this city in the electrical business with Thomas A. Edison and Mr. Gilliland.  All of Mr. Gaston's friends had it settled in their own minds that he would die a bachelor.  His business frequently called hi to New York.  While in town he spent much of his time with Mr. Gilliland.  Every time he came to New York Mr. Gilliland invited Gaston to make his home at Pelham Manor.  Gaston invariably refused, saying that the Gilliland House was always filled with guests and that he hadn't time to play the agreeable to a lot of women.  Then the man from Indianapolis would picture to his old friend what large times the two might have if Gililland would only stay with Gaston in town.

'Break away, old man,' he would say, 'and we'll have some fun that deserves to be called fun!  I can't see anything in talking one's self black in the face of a houseful of women.'

One day last February Gaston arrived in New York on one of his business trips.  His two sisters had been visiting Mr. and Mrs. Gilliland for several weeks, and in their letters home they had frequently mentioned Miss Ethel Bishop, a very charming English girl, who was making her home at the Gillilands.  From those letters Gaston had learned that Miss Bishop had been born in Shanghai, while her father was serving the English government there as Consul.  As a child she had lived in Africa, her gather having been transferred to one of the South African States.  Later she had been sent to a convent in Paris whence she went to Heidelberg, and there she took a degree in music.  Then she went to London to continue her studies in music and the classics.  In fact, Gaston heard so much about Miss Bishop that, when he reached New York and Mr. Gilliland extended to him the usual invitation to visit Pelham Manor, the Indianapolis man said emphatically, 'Not much!'

Finally, on St. Valentine's Day, the day before he was to return home, Gaston consented to go out to Pelham Manor for a few hours, just to see his sisters.  He went and stayed two weeks.  He was done for, but he could not bring himself to the point of a proposal.  As he himself said last night:

'I came pretty close to it several times, but when I got just to the point I got scared.  I felt as if it would be a sort of sacrilege that I mustn't be guilty of.  I tell you, I never thought a woman could bluff me out; and so I went home.'

When he returned to Indianapolis he wasn't able to do much business.  All he could think about was the English girl on the shore of Long Island Sound.  Two weeks went by and one morning while he was sitting in his office a letter came from one of his sisters.  It was largely filled with a description of a german she had danced a few nights before, and told how all the men had simply gone daft about Miss Bishop.  Gaston thought for a moment, and then rushed to the telephone, looked up the number of Gilliland's house telephone in the long-distance telephone book, and asked to be connected.  Pretty soon he heard a feminine voice at the other end of the line call, 'Hello!'

'Hello!  Who is that?' answered Gaston.  'Who?  Oh!  Miss Bishop?  Well, this is Mr. Gaston Miss Bishop.  Where am I?  In Indianapolis.  Yes, in Indianapolis.  I thought I'd call you up to -- to ask how my sisters are.  You'll call one of them and let her speak for herself?  Oh, never mind, I said 'never mind.'  N-e-v-e-r-never.  No, not mine; mind -- m-i-n-d.  Hello!  How are you?  Just going to the city?  Theatre party to-night?  Oh, not going in till the 4 o'clock train?  Wish I were going with you.  I said I wish I were going with you.  I don't know whether my sisters would like to have me or not.  I just wanted to go with you.  Don't be foolish?  Hello!  What did you say?  Hello!  Hello!  Say, Central!  Don't cut me off!  I'm not through talking yet.  Gone at the other end?  Well, ring up again.'

As Mr. Gaston said last night, he was bound to say something then or die in the attempt.  After waiting some time, he got the Gilliland house again and began talking with Miss Bishop.

'I beat about the bush for a long time,' he said, 'and then I came out with the question.  She evidently couldn't understand me, for this was the answer I got:

'Come a little nearer Mr. Gaston.  I can't hear you.'

'Then I moved about one inch nearer to her in that eight hundred miles and asked the question over again.  This time it was perfectly understood.  I was told that I might not be sure of myself, that I had better wait for a while, and some more things like that.  I said I had lived to be 35 years old, and I guessed I knew my own mind.  Finally I was told that she would give me an answer when she called me up in two weeks.'

That was on Feb. 28.  Two weeks after that Miss Bishop was in Brooklyn one day and stepped into the office of Mr. Gilliland.  She called up Mr. Gaston.

'Hello!  Is that you Mr. Gaston?  This is Miss Bishop.  Knew the voice, did you?  Your memory for sound is excellent.  I wonder if it is as good for other things.  One other thing?  What's that?  Oh, my answer?  Was I to give you an answer about anything?  Hello!  What's that?  I know very well I was?  Yes I guess I do.  Two weeks have seemed like two years?  You say that very nicely -- over the telephone.  Well, are you sure you knew what you were talking about?  Positive?  And you don't think you'll regret it some time?  Sure?  Well, then, if you want yes, here it is.  What's that?  Hello!  What did you say?  Oh!  Well, you can't have that over the telephone.  You must come for that yourself.  Good-by, George.'

It wasn't long before he came for what he couldn't get over the telephone, and the arrangements for the wedding were made.  Mr. and Mrs. Gaston are now at the Imperial, but this evening they will leave for Indianapolis, their future home.  Mrs. Gaston is an unusually good-looking woman, perhaps 22 years old.  She has dark hair, large dark eyes, and a graceful figure.  She has a musical voice, and speaks with a decided English accent.  Speaking of her engagement, she said:

'I have travelled over a good bit of the world and heard of plenty of romances, but I never dreamed that I should come to America to get engaged by telephone.  And I shouldn't if George hadn't been such a dear fellow, with such an awful lot of cheek at long distance.'"

Source:  PROPOSED BY TELEPHONE -- GOT A 'YES,' TOO, OVER RIGHT HUNDRED MILES OF WIRE -- One End Each of Two Conversations Between George B. Gaston in Indianapolis and Etel Mary Bishop Right Here -- Married at Pelham Manor Last Tuesday, The Sun [NY, NY], Nov. 30, 1895, Vol. LXIII, No. 91, p. 1, col. 5.  See also PROPOSED BY TELEPHONE, The Shepherdstown Register [Shepherdstown, WV], Dec. 12, 1895, New Vol. 31, No. 8, p. 1, col. 4 (same text); Proposed by Telephone -- GOT A 'YES,' TOO, OVER EIGHT HUNDRED MILES OF WIRE, Shenandoah Herald [Woodstock, VA], Dec. 20, 1895, Vol. 70, No. 39, p. 1, col. 2 (same text). 



Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, May 02, 2017

More on Ezra T. Gillilland of Pelham Manor, Inventor of the Telephone Switchboard and Friend of Thomas Edison


When most think of the inventor of the telephone and the phonograph, most think of Thomas Alva Edison.  Pelhamites, however, think of Pelham Manor resident Ezra Torrence Gilliland who actually assisted Edison in the creation and improvement of both inventions.  Gilliland further invented, on his own, the original telephone switchboard, the magneto bell, and a host of other technologies that were mainstays of the American telephone system for nearly a century.  

Ezra Torrence Gilliland was a prolific 19th century inventor and one of the most creative people ever to live in Pelham.  He served as one of the earliest village trustees of the Village of Pelham Manor, beginning his service in 1893 only two years after the Village was formed.  He later became President (i.e., Mayor) of the Village of Pelham Manor and served in that capacity until shortly before his death on May 13, 1903.  He also served for a time as President of the old Manor Club before that club became a women's club.  In 1893 Gilliland's wife, Lillian M. Johnson Gilliland, joined the board of The Pelham Home for Children and served in that capacity for many years.



Ezra T. Gilliland in an Undated Photograph.

I have written before about famed Pelham Manor inventor Ezra T. Gilliland and his wife, Lillian Johnson Gilliland.  See: 

Tue., Aug. 04, 2015:  Ezra T. Gilliland, The Inventor of the Telephone Switchboard and Friend of Thomas Edison, Was a Pelham Manor Resident.  

Thu., Aug. 13, 2015:  Lillian Johnson Gilliland's Memories of Thomas Edison and 19th Century Life in Pelham Manor.

Ezra and Lillian Gilliland moved to Pelham Manor in 1891 or 1892.  The Gillilands built their Pelham Manor home on a corner lot where Secor Avenue (now Secor Lane) meets Wolfs Lane.  Some sources indicate Ezra Gilliland's laboratory was built on the adjacent lot with frontage on Secor Avenue.  Others indicate that his lab was on the second floor of the home.  Yet others indicate his laboratory was in the basement of the home.  Most likely, he did laboratory work at various places in and around the home during the twelve or so years he lived there in Pelham Manor.  



Detail from Map Published in 1899 Showing Location of Home and
Laboratory of Ezra T. Gilliland. "Secor Ave." Since Has Been Extended
Across and Beyond Wolfs Lane and Now is Known as "Secor Lane."
Source: Fairchild, John F., Atlas of the City of Mount Vernon and the Town
of Pelham, Plate 22 (Mount Vernon, NY: John F. Fairchild, 1899).  NOTE:
Click on Image to Enlarge.

Today's posting to the Historic Pelham Blog transcribes two obituaries published at the time of Ezra T. Gilliland's death.  They are significant because they provide additional details of his life during his time in Indianapolis before he and his wife moved to Pelham Manor.  



"EZRA T. GILLILAND."  Source:  E. T. GILLILAND DIED AT HIS NEW YORK
ASSOCIATED WITH EDISONIndianapolis News, May 13, 1903,
p. 11, cols. 3-4.  NOTE:  Click on Image to Enlgarge.


*          *          *          *          *

Below is the text of two obituaries that appeared after Ezra T. Gilliland's death.  Each is followed by a citation and link to its source.  

"Ezra T. Gilliland.

Ezra T. Gilliland, an inventor, to whom many of the improvements of the American Bell telephone are due, died Wednesday from Bright's disease at his home in Pelham Manor.  Mr. Gilliland was the inventor of the original bell switchboard, of the magneto bell and many other contrivances now in use by the company.  On the upper floors of his home he had a large laboratory, where he worked almost to the day of his death, solving problems of electricity.  He was an intimate friend of Thomas A. Edison, and they worked jointly on several inventions.  He was interested in the Gilliland Electrical Company, which has large factories in Adrian, Mich., and when he had perfected and patented his inventions he sent the models there to be duplicated for the market.  He kept seven expert electricians employed in the laboratory at his home.  He was for several years a director in the Bell Telephone Co.  He had served as trustee and president of Pelham Manor.

Mr. Gilliland was born in Cuba, N.Y., fifty-six years ago, and lived most of his life in New York.  He was a member of the Reform, Manhattan, Colonial, Pelham Manor, New York Athletic and Columbia Yacht Clubs.  He leaves a widow, who was Miss Lilian Johnson, of Indianapolis.  The funeral was held yesterday at his home.  The Rev. Harris E. Adriance, of New York, formerly pastor of the Pelham Manor Presbyterian Church, officiated.  The burial will be in Adrian, Mich., which is the home of Mr. Gilliland's mother and brother."

Source:  Ezra T. Gilliland, New Rochelle Pioneer, May 16, 1903, Vol. 45, No. 8, p. 8, col. 3.

"E. T. GILLILAND DIED AT HIS NEW YORK HOME
-----
A FAMOUS INVENTOR -- KNOWN IN INDIANAPOLIS.
-----
ASSOCIATED WITH EDISON
-----

Ezra Torrence Gilliland, age fifty-eight years, died at his home in Pelham Manor, West Chester county, New York, this morning.  He had been a sufferer from Bright's disease.  He began to fail four or five months ago and death was not unexpected.  He was born in New York State on June 17, 1845.  He was well-known in Indianapolis.

He opened the first telephone exchange in this city, and during his residence here he was married to Miss Lillian M. Johnson, the daughter of Captain Johnson, formerly of Madison.  At various times he has been interested in business ventures in Indianapolis, and socially he was well known.  The funeral arrangements have not yet been made.  He will probably be buried in New York or in Adrian, Mich.

Mr. Gilliland began life as a telegraph operator on the line of the Michigan Central or the Lake Shore railroad, and in his boyhood days became acquainted with Edison.  This developed into a friendship which lasted all through life.  They were associated in many business enterprises, and in the development of the telephone and phonograph he shared honors with Mr. Edison.

Inventor of Switchboard.

The fundamental principles of the switchboard, used by every telephone system throughout the world, is an invention of Mr. Gilliland, and the perfected transmitter is also the result of his work.

Mr. Gilliland organized and constructed the first telephone exchange in Indianapolis, which at that time was situated in the Vance Block -- at present the Indiana Trust Block.  That was in the '70s.  He owned that exchange and the Indiana rights of the telephone and he operated the Indianapolis exchange for a year or more and sold it to a syndicate for $20,000.  This syndicate, within twenty-four hours, turned it into the Central Union company for $1,000,000.

His reasons for disposing of the telephone exchange and his rights in Indiana was prompted by his love for mechanics.  With the money obtained by the sale of the property he started the Gilliland Electric Manufacturing Company.  The business prospered and outgrew the quarters and he bought the old factory of the Indianapolis Shoe Company, on Brookside avenue.  He carried on the business there for three years and moved his factory to Adrian, Mich.  The Adrian plant became one of the largest electrical manufacturing houses in the United States.  

For thirty years he manufactured equipment for the Western Union and he made practically all of the insulating pins that carry Western Union lines over the country.

One of his latest inventions was a cigarette-making machine which has a capacity of 500 cigarettes a minute.  This machine was made with a view of entering into competition with other cigarette manufacturing machinery controlled by the French government.  It has been adopted by the Havana Commercial Company, which has monopolized the business in Cuba.

Mr. Gilliland left a considerable fortune.  At times he has been worth over a million dollars.  He was affable, kindly and hospitable.  

Mrs. Danforth Brown, of Indianapolis, is a sister of Mrs. Gilliland, and has gone to the funeral."

Source:  E. T. GILLILAND DIED AT HIS NEW YORK HOME -- A FAMOUS INVENTOR -- KNOWN IN INDIANAPOLIS -- ASSOCIATED WITH EDISON, Indianapolis News, May 13, 1903, p. 11, cols. 3-4.  

Archive of the Historic Pelham Web Site.

Labels: , , , , ,

Thursday, August 13, 2015

Lillian Johnson Gilliland's Memories of Thomas Edison and 19th Century Life in Pelham Manor


Lillian M. Johnson Gilliland was the wife of famed inventor Ezra Torrence Gilliland.  She lived in Pelham for nearly fifty years.  She and her husband arrived in about 1891 or 1892 and built a house and an adjacent laboratory building near the intersection of Wolfs Lane and Secor Avenue (now known as Secor Lane).  I have written about Lillian Gilliland and her husband, Ezra Gilliland, before.  See, e.g.:

Tue., Aug. 4, 2015:  Ezra T. Gilliland, The Inventor of the Telephone Switchboard and Friend of Thomas Edison, Was a Pelham Manor Resident.

Fri., Feb. 13, 2015:  A Magical Valentine's Day in Pelham Manor in 1895.

Although Ezra Gilliland died on May 13, 1903, Lillian Gilliland remained in Pelham for nearly the next four decades.  In 1938 she gave a lengthy interview to a reporter from The Pelham Sun.  She provided her recollections of her husband's extensive involvement with Thomas Edison in the 1870s and 1880s.  She also recalled her and her husband's early days in Pelham Manor, shortly after the Village of Pelham Manor was created in 1891.  The resultant article provides a quaint snapshot of a simpler llife in Peham Manor more than 120 years ago.  The text of the article is transcribed below, followed by a citation to its source. 



Mrs. Ezra T. Gilliland in 1938.
Sep. 9, 1938, p. 3, cols. 1-5.
NOTE:  Click Image to Enlarge.

Good Times Began At Home and Stayed There In The Old Days In The Manor
-----
Mrs. Ezra T. Gilliland Who Will Celebrate 80th Birthday in December Recalls Neighborhood Character of Social Life in Pelham Manor in the Early Days of the Village.
-----

‘We were just like one big family then,’ Mrs. Ezra T. Gilliland long-time resident of Pelham Manor told a Pelham Sun reporter when questioned at her home on Boston Post Road, about life in the old days of the village. 

Speaking of the old days on Secor Hill, Mrs. Gilliland who will celebrate her 80th birthday on next December 13th, recalls with relish and a slight nostalgic sorrow the joys of other days; days filled to overflowing with gaiety and movement, joys in which many neighbors shared, both summer and winter, joys in which the home was often both the beginning and the end.

Mrs. Gilliland, who is small and dainty, with the quick neat grace of a bird, has weathered many changes in Pelham Manor since the days very early in the 90’s when she and her husband came from New York to make their home here.  Her husband, who died in 1903 was widely known as a successful inventor.  He was at one time associated with the American Bell Telephone Company and with the late Thomas Alvah Edison.  Much of the apparatus designed by the late Mr. Gilliland is now in the Smithsonian Institute.  He served as president of the Village of Pelham Manor and was an active and leading figure in the early days of the community.  He was also president of the old Manor Club.

‘We hunted around in Connecticut and had almost decided on Davenport Neck in New Rochelle when we finally determined to come to Pelham Manor,’ Mrs. Gilliland recalled.  The branch line of the New Haven railroad then active made commuting  a simple enough proposition.  About 1892 she and her husband built a home on Wolf’s Lane, the house now occupied by the Ely family.  Mr Gilliland soon built a laboratory for his experimental work right next door.

Mrs. Gilliland recalls the none too frequent houses that then stood in this section of the Manor known as Secor Hill, among them the old Secor house, now the residence of Mrs. Julius Manger and also the home of Mr. James Secor on Boston Post Road at Ely avenue.  The playwright, Joseph Arthur, author of ‘Blue Jeans,’ came to the Manor to live through friendship with the Gillilands.  The Geise family then resided in what is now the residence of Mrs. John Clyde Oswald. 

The reporter walking up the Boston Post Road to Mrs. Gilliland’s residence speculated on the changes that have taken place along the historic highway.  The sweet smell of newly cut grass spoke of the country but was rudely obliterated the second after by the nauseating fumes from the exhaust of a passing truck.  The highways tell the story, thought the reporter. 

Mrs. Danforth Brown who for 17 years served as manager of the Manor Club starting at the time when it became a women’s club in 1914, makes her home with Mrs. Gilliland her sister in Pelham Manor.  She told with humorous appreciation of a day long ago when she remembers Mr. Gilliland calling to his wife ‘Come to the window, here comes an automobile.’  An automobile, if you please, and on the Boston Post Road of all places!  On another occasion, both Mrs. Gilliland and Mrs. Brown recall Mr. Gilliland rushing out of the house, armed with whiskey to help resuscitate a wretched horse that had been overcome as he toiled up the hill on the Post Road on a terrifically hot summer day.

Speaking of the Boston Post road and traffic, Mrs. Gilliland related with glee that when there was some talk of extending the New Rochelle Trolley up the Post Road to connect with the New York line, the old residents on Secor Hill strenuously objected on the grounds of too much noise.

The Gilliland family were long friends of the late Thomas A. Edison and in fact, it was at their summer home in Winthrop, Mass., that Mr. Edison met Mina Miller who was to become the second Mrs. Edison.  A pleasant interlude came into their life when they spent about a year abroad while Mr. Gilliland was busy installing a factory in Antwerp.  Mrs. Gilliland had an interesting experience at that time while traveling in Italy when she went to use a telephone and saw staring her in the face the words ‘Gilliland Patent.’  The old-fashioned bell for ringing the operator was devised by Mr. Gilliland.

Way back in 1885 when Mrs. Brown, then a Miss Johnson and a student at the Conservatory of Music in Boston, recalls demonstrating the first wax records made for the old-fashioned phonographs at the Boston Exposition.  Mrs. Brown to the great interest of many visitors at the Exposition, sang a song and a record was made so that her voice could be heard again through the medium of the talking machine.  She recalls the crowds but fails to remember the title of the sond.  Mr. Gilliland collaborated with Mr. Edison on the phonography invention.

Returning to memories of old Pelham Manor, Mrs. Gilliland volunteered casually the startling information ‘We used to play golf here on the corner, at the intersection of Highland avenue and Boston Post Road, on a small neighborhood course.’  She recalled too annual summer clambakes she and her husband used to have on their lawn, with preparations for days beforehand and the chef from the New York Athletic Club presiding. 

‘There was no depression then, no President Roosevelt,’ Mrs. Brown interpolated with a sigh for the good old days.

‘We made our own pleasures at home,’ Mrs. Gilliland said.  Young people, she added, know nothing of those ‘primitive days.’  There were no movies, no ubiquitous automobiles.  People were dependent on themselves and on their neighbors to make their own good times.

Mrs. Gilliland remembers bicycle parties of about eight persons who would pedal along Split Rock Road down to the Clairmont Inn on Riverside Drive where dinner had already been ordered.  After dining the party would bicycle over to the Grand Central Station and stow their bikes in the baggage car, returning home by the ‘main line.’

The Winter with its snows and ice brought gay sleighing parties, merry with bells on the frosty air.  After gay rides the parties would often wind up at the New York Athletic Club.  Mr. Gilliland would have the tennis court flooded for skating, providing fun for the entire neighborhood. 

Music too, played an important part in the social life of those more leisurely days of the 90’s and early 1900’s.  Both Mr. and Mrs. Gilliland were actively fond of music and it was as their guest that the Italian tenor, Campanini came to Pelham Manor and sang at the old Manor Club, his last appearance in this country.  The noted tenor was accustomed to drink a pint of champagne before giving a performance.  The iron-clad rules of the old Manor Club were lifted on this occasion in order that the tenor might quaff his wine before lifting his voice in song.

With particular enthusiasm and an obviously sincere admiration for her many fine quantities, Mrs. Gilliland speaks of the late Mrs. Joan E. Secor, a brilliant, gracious and leading figure in the old days of Pelham Manor.  A leader of the Tuesday Afternoon Club, Mrs. Secor was to carry on her cultural activities in the Manor Club when it became a Woman’s Club. 

Mrs. Brown recalls the old Toonerville Trolley with affectionate memory.  She lived on Pelhamdale Avenue for some time and remembers one particularly stormy Winter night when the car was stalled in front of her home.  She supplied the motorman with hot coffee and food during the long night hours when he refused to leave the car, hoping that help might come at any moment to dig him out of the drifts.

Mrs. Gilliland moves along with the times, keeping her club interests formed so many years ago.  She is an honorary member of the Manor Club now and was the first chairman of the club house committee.  Mrs. Gilliland was honored last Spring for long association with the Pelham Home, having served as a board member since the founding of the cardiac institution on Split Rock Road.”


Labels: , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, August 04, 2015

Ezra T. Gilliland, The Inventor of the Telephone Switchboard and Friend of Thomas Edison, Was a Pelham Manor Resident


Ezra Torrence Gilliland was a prolific 19th century inventor and one of the most creative people ever to live in Pelham.  He served as one of the earliest village trustees of the Village of Pelham Manor, beginning his service in 1893 only two years after the Village was formed.  He later became President (i.e., Mayor) of the Village of Pelham Manor and served in that capacity until shortly before his death on May 13, 1903.  He also served for a time as President of the old Manor Club before that club became a women's club.  In 1893 Gilliland's wife, Lillian M. Johnson Gilliland, joined the board of The Pelham Home for Children and served in that capacity for many years.



Ezra Torrence Gilliland in an Undated Photograph.

Gilliland was born in New York in 1846, a son of Robert C. Gilliland and his wife, Caroline.  As a youngster, Ezra lived with his family in Portville and in Allegany Township, both in Cattaraugus County, New York.  As a young man, he became a telegrapher.  By the beginning of the Civil War, Ezra Gilliland had become an expert telegraph operator.  By the age of 24, he had moved to Cincinnati, Ohio and had begun tinkering as an inventor.  

After invention of the telephone Gilliland became interested both as a manufacturer and an improver. According to his obituary in the New York Times, "Chief among his inventions are the Gilliland bell, for attracting the attention of  “central”, the Gilliland switch board, now in common use, and the exchange, of which he gave the original idea."

Gilliland was, at one time, a close friend of Thomas Edison.  The pair got to know each other in about the early 1870s while working with telegraph equipment.  They became fast friends, even referring to themselves as "Damon and Pythias."  They built summer resort homes next to each other in Fort Myers, Florida.   Gilliland and his wife even introduced Edison to his second wife, Mina Miller, during a visit by Edison to see the Gillilands in Boston.  

During the late 1870s, Gilliland presented tinfoil phonograph "exhibitions" throughout the midwest, trying to drum up public interest in the invention.  During the 1880s, Gilliland worked with Edison in various aspects of the improvement of the phonograph and became a major investor in the Edison Phonograph Company.  The pair had a falling out over ownership of the Edison Phonograph Company.  Edison even sued Gilliland in a lawsuit that attracted national attention, alleging that Gilliland and his lawyer friend, John C. Tomlinson, cut a secret deal to profit from the phonograph behind Edison's back.  In April, 1890, a judge ruled against Thomas Edison and in favor of Ezra Gilliland in the matter.  Thomas Edison reportedly never spoke with Ezra Gilliland again.  



Advertisement that Appeared in the June 4, 1878 Issue
of the Cincinnati Daily Gazette Touting an Exhibition
of the Tinfoil Phonograph Managed by Ezra T. Gilliland.
NOTE:  Click Image to Enlarge.


Gilliland married Lillian M. Johnson on February 5, 1880 in Indianapolis, Indiana.  The couple lived there for a period of time.  While there, Gilliland was granted three patents for two telephone apparatuses and a driving gear for a magneto electric machine.  

For many years Mr. Gilliland oversaw the Bell Telephone Company’s "experiment station" in Boston.  While there, according to the New York Times, he "did most of his important work." Gilliland also was one of the organizers of the Western Electric Company.  

Among Gilliland's many inventions was the telephone switchboard.  On April 30, 1895 the United States Patent and Trademark Office issued Letters Patent Number 538,327 for an invention by Gilliland called the "Telephone Central-Office System". According to the patent: 

"The system herein described is particularly adapted for use with small exchanges and a magneto telephone system. It is of great importance that the apparatus should be simplified as much as possible and that the line should be kept as clear as possible so as to make the fullest use of the current developed by the voice, for its strength is necessarily limited and should be utilized to its full advantage. With these two objects in view I provide a system in which when two subscribers are connected the annunciator drop of one of them is retained in the circuits as a clearing out drop while the other is shunted out. Special clearing out drops are therefore unnecessary. To effect this I attach to an ordinary spring-jack and additional or auxiliary contact plate which is connected with the subscriber's leading-in wire before it passes through the drop, and I provide a pair of plugs on the opposite ends of two strands of wire, one of the plubs having a plate which contacts with the additional contact and excludes the drop from the circuit, the other having a plate which contacts only with the contact that is connected to line through the drop, thereby including the drop in the circuit. When two subscribers are connected through their spring jacks and such a pair of plugs, the result is that the annunciator drop of one of the subscribers is in the circuit and the annunciator drop of the other subscriber is out of the circuit. This apparatus embodies the main feature of my invention." 

Gilliland's patent including its abstract, drawings, description and claims may be accessed by clicking here.



Ezra T. Gilliland's Patent Drawing Included with United States
Patent and Trademark Office Letters Patent Number 538,327
for an Invention by Gilliland Called the "Telephone
Central-Office System"  NOTE:  Click Image to Enlarge.

In about 1891 or 1892, Gilliland and his wife began looking for a home near New York City.  According to Mrs. Gilliland, "We hunted around in Connecticut and had almost decided on Davenport Neck in New Rochelle when we finally determined to come to Pelham Manor."  In about 1892, the Gillilands built a home on Wolfs Lane in the Village of Pelham Manor.  Soon thereafter they built a laboratory for Ezra's "experimental work" next door.  See Good Times Began At Home and Stayed There In The Old Days In The Manor – Mrs. Ezra T. Gilliland Who Will Celebrate 80th Birthday in December Recalls Neighborhood Character of Social Life in Pelham Manor in the Early Days of the Village, The Pelham Sun, Sep. 9, 1938, p. 3, cols. 1-5.

The Gillilands built their Pelham Manor home on a corner lot where Secor Avenue (now Secor Lane) meets Wolfs Lane.  The laboratory was built on the adjacent lot with frontage on Secor Avenue.  



Detail from Map Published in 1899 Showing Location of Home
and Laboratory of Ezra T. Gilliland.  "Secor Ave." Since Has
Been Extended Across and Beyond Wolfs Lane and Now is
Known as "Secor Lane."  Source:  Fairchild, John F., Atlas of the
City of Mount Vernon and the Town of Pelham, Plate 22
(Mount Vernon, NY:  John F. Fairchild, 1899).
NOTE:  Click on Image to Enlarge.

The couple cherished their time in Pelham Manor.  They played golf on a "small neighborhood course" once located at the intersection of Highland Avenue and Boston Post Road.  They had a tennis court on their property and flooded it during winter to allow neighbors to ice skate.  They held lavish clambakes on their property and enjoyed bicycling throughout the region.  See Good Times Began At Home and Stayed There In The Old Days In The Manor – Mrs. Ezra T. Gilliland Who Will Celebrate 80th Birthday in December Recalls Neighborhood Character of Social Life in Pelham Manor in the Early Days of the VillageThe Pelham Sun, Sep. 9, 1938, p. 3, cols. 1-5.

Ezra Torrence Gilliland died from heart disease at the age of fifty-five in his Pelham Manor home on May 13, 1903.  His wife continued to live in Pelham Manor for nearly forty years thereafter and remained active in the Manor Club over which her husband had once presided.  

*          *          *          *          *

Below is transcribed text from a variety of sources relating to the life of Ezra Torrence Gilliland of Pelham Manor.  Each is followed by a citation to its source.  Links are included when available.  

"DEATH OF E. T. GILLILAND
-----
He Was the Inventor of Appliances for
Improving Telephone Service.

Ezra Torrence Gilliland died yesterday from heart disease at his home in Pelham Manor in his fifty-fifth year. Mr. Gilliland was a native of Adrian, Mich. At the beginning of the civil war he became an expert telegraph operator, and when the telephone was invented he became interested both as a manufacturer and improver. Chief among his inventions are the Gilliland bell, for attracting the attention of  “central”, the Gilliland switch board, now in common use, and the exchange, of which he gave the original idea.

For many years Mr. Gilliland was in charge of the Bell Telephone Company’s experiment station in Boston and while there did most of his important work. He was one of the organizers of the Western Electric company and was also associated with Thomas A. Edison for several years.

Of late years Mr. Gilliland had not been active in electrical work. Up to a year ago he held the Presidency of Pelham Manor. A widow survives him. The funeral will take place at Pelham Manor on Friday at 10 o’clock. Interment will be at Adrian, Mich."

Source:  DEATH OF E. T. GILLILAND -- He Was the Inventor of Appliances for
Improving Telephone Service, N.Y. Times, May 14, 1903.

"Ezra T. Gilliland was born in 1846 at New York.2,1  He was the son of Robert C. Gilliland and Caroline G. ?.1  Ezra T. Gilliland appeared on the 1850 Federal Census of Portville, Cattaraugus County, New York, in the household of his parents, Robert C. Gilliland and Caroline G. ?.1  Ezra T. Gilliland appeared on the 1860 Federal Census of Allegany township, Cattaraugus County, New York, in the household of his parents, Robert C. Gilliland and Caroline G. ?.3  Ezra T. Gilliland appeared on the 1870 Federal Census of Cincinnati, Hamilton County, Ohio, enumerated 2 June 1870.4  

Ezra T. Gilliland married Lillian M. Johnson on 5 February 1880 at Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana.5,6  Ezra T. Gilliland and Lillian M. Johnson appeared on the 1880 Federal Census of Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana, enumerated 14 June 1880.5  In 1889, Ezra was in a legal dispute with Thomas A. Edison.7  Ezra T. Gilliland and Lillian M. Johnson appeared on the 1900 Federal Census of Pelham, Westchester County, New York, enumerated 11 June 1900.8  Ezra T. Gilliland died on 13 May 1903 at Pelham, Westchester County, New York.2,9,10  He was buried at Oakwood Cemetery, Adrian, Lenawee County, Michigan.2  (For burial information see Find-a-Grave.) 

Ezra was a telegrapher and a close friend of Thomas A. Edison.11  He was also an inventor in his own right. While living in Indianapolis he was granted patents for three devices: a driving gear for a magneto electric machine, and two telephone apparatuses.12  An article written by historian John T. Cunningham and published in the Elyria Chronicle Telegram on August 15, 1979, tells of the friendship between Edison and Ezra and how Edison met this second wife, Mina Miller, at the Gilliland's home when they were living in Boston.11  However, sometime in early 1889 Ezra and Thomas became entangled in a bitter business dispute. Edison charged Ezra and a lawyer, John C. Tomlinson, with "treachery and breach of faith" and filed a suit in the U.S. Circuit Court.7  In April 1890, a judge rules against Edison and for the defendants Ezra T. Gilliland and John C. Tomlinson.13  

Citations 

1.  [S5347] Robt. Gilleland household, 1850 U.S. census, Cattaraugus County, New York, population schedule, Portville, page 241, dwelling 30, family 30.; Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com). 

2.  [S5374] Ezra T. Gilliland, online http://www.findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi 

3.  [S5358] Robert Gillerland household, 1860 U.S. census, Cattaraugus County, New York, population schedule, Allegany township, PO Allegany, page 1, dwelling 10, family 10.; Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com). 

4.  [S5390] Wilford Baker household, 1870 U.S. census, Hamilton County, Ohio, population schedule, Cincinnati 14th Ward, PO Cincinnati, page 21, dwelling 122, family 121.; Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com). 

5.  [S5391] Ezra T. Gilleland household, 1880 Federal Census, Marion County, Indiana, population schedule, Indianapolis, ED 115, page/sheet 42, dwelling 326, family 381.; Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com). 

6.  [S5392] Marion County (Indiana). Clerk of the Circuit Court. Marriage records 1877-1881, microfilm, access date: January 14, 2014, Film 0499373, Family History Library, 35 North West Temple Street, Salt Lake City, Utah. 

7.  [S5395] New York World, May 13, 1889. 

8.  [S5393] Ezra T. Gilliland household, 1900 U.S. census, Westchester County, New York, population schedule, Pelham, ED 109, page/sheet 5A, dwelling 55, family 55.; Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com). 

9.  [S5398] Logansport Reporter, May 15, 1903, front page. 

10.  [S5400] Unknown author, "Death of Ezra T. Gilliland." 

11.  [S5396] Elyria Chronicle Telegram, August 15, 1979. 

12.  [S5397] Sullivan Times, February 23, 1884. 

13.  [S5399] New York Times, April 11, 1890."

Source:  Gilliland Families -- Finding John Gilliland, Person Page 244 (visited Jul. 27, 2015).


"WAS INVENTOR OF THE SWITCHBOARD
-----
Death of the Man Who Gave the First Impetus to Telephones in Indiana.
-----
Sold for $20,000 What Was Worth $1,000,000
-----

The death of Ezra T. Gilliland Wednesday at his home in Westchester county, New York, closed the life of a man whose genius had a great deal to do with the remarkable development and utilization of the telephone.

Mr. Gilliland began life as telegraph operator on the line of the Michigan Central on the Lake Shore railroad and in his boyhood days became acquainted with Edison. This developed into a friendship which lasted all through life. They were associated in many business enterprises, and in the development of the telephone and phonograph he shared honors with Mr. Edison.

The fundamental principles of the switchboard, used by every telephone system throughout the world, is an invention of Mr. Gilliland, and the perfected transmitter is also the result of his work.

Mr. Gilliland organized and contructed the first telephone exchange in Indianapolis, which at that time was situated in the Vance block -- at present the Indiana Trust block. That was in the ‘70s. He owned that exchange and the Indiana rights of the telephone, and he operated the Indianapolis exchange for a year or more and sold it to a syndicate for $20,000. This syndicate, within twenty-four hours, turned it into the Central Union company for $1,000,000.

His reasons for disposing of the telephone exchange and his rights in Indiana was prompted by his love for mechanics. With the money obtained by the sale of the property he started the Gilliland Electric Manufacturing company, at Indianapolis. The business prospered and outgrew the quarters and he bought the old factory of the Indianapolis Shoe company, on Brookside avenue. He carried on the business there for three years and moved his factory to Adrian, Mich. The Adrian plant became on of the largest electrical and manufacturing houses in the United States.

For thirty years he manufactured equipment for the Western Union, and he made practically all of the insulating pins that carry Western Union lines over the country.

One of his latest inventions was a cigarette making machine which has a capacity of 500 cigarettes a minute. This machine was made with a view of entering into competition with other cigarette manufacturing machinery controlled by the French government. It has been adopted by the Havanna Commercial company, which has monopolized the business in Cuba.

Source:  WAS INVENTOR OF THE SWITCHBOARD -- Death of the Man Who Gave First Impetus to Telephones in Indiana -- Sold for $20,000 What Was Worth $1,000,000, Logansport Reporter [Logansport, Indiana], May 15, 1903.  

"The Phonograph.

Yesterday Mr. E. T. Gilliland began the public exhibitions of Edison's speaking phonograph in Greenwood Hall.  Three exhibitions were given -- one in the forenoon, one in the afternoon and one in the evening.  Their style is pleasantly informal.  Mr. Gilliland and his instrument, standing in the middle of the hall with his auditors and spectators gathered around him while he explains the operations of the marvelous piece of mechanism, answers any questions that may be put, and exhibits its powers in the same way that was described last week when he gave the newspaper writers a hearing.  As a means of entertainment and as a study to those thoughtfully inclined, the instrument was shown to have great interest, and many there were who returned several times to listen to the miraculous voice.  Mr. Gilliland's explanations are exceedingly simple and unaffected with technical terms, and he seems to take delight in bringing the most marvelous of inventions right down to the comprehension of the veriest tyro in the study of mind and its phenomena.  The exhibitions will continue several days in Greenwood Hall."

Source:  The Phonograph, Cincinnati Daily Gazette, June 4, 1878.

"WAS MR. EDISON GULLED?
-----
He Sues Gilliland and Tomlinson, Charging Broken Faith and Treachery.

THE WORLD recently announced that Thomas A. Edison had discovered that Ezra T. Gilliland and John C. Tomlinson had sold to Jesse H. Lippincott the agency held by Gilliland for the sale of phonographs for $250,000, in alleged breach of contracct, and on representations that they received only $75,000.  Suit has now been begun in the United States Circuit Court by Mr. Edison, charging Gilliland and Tomlinson with treachery and breach of faith and demanding an accounting.  In his complaint Edison says that he induced Gilliland to join him in business by offering him a larger salary than he had been receiving from the Bell Telephone Company, and that he made Tomlinson wealthy by giving him large retainers as counsel.  Gilliland was made general agent for the sale of the phonographs, but he agreed to hold this monopoly at the control of Edison.  He further says that the defendants induced him to sell his 11,960 shares of the Edison Phonograph Company to Lippincott for $500,000, and then they sold the agency to the same person, virtually making him sole owner of the business.  The defendants put in a general denial.

Mr. Tomlinson says that neither he nor Gilliland is a beneficiary of Edison, but, on the contrary, they have lost heavily through their connection with him.  The sale of the agency was a perfectly fair and honorable transaction.  He denies that they told Edison that they were to receive only $75,000, but that they had accepted $250,000 of the stock in the new company, and subsequently sold the stock to Lippincott for $250,000.

The case will probably come to trial in June, Edison's counsel being Col. Robert G. Ingersoll and Eaton & Lewis, while Frederick R. Coudert and W. Bourke Cockran are for Gilliland and Tomlinson."

Source:   WAS MR. EDISON GULLED? -- He Sues Gilliland and Tomlinson, Charging Broken Faith and Treachery, N.Y. World, May 13, 1889.

"AGAINST EDISON.
-----
THE WIZARD'S SUIT AGAINST GILLILAND AND TOMLINSON DECIDED.

Judge Wallace of the United States Circuit Court yesterday handed down a decision sustaining the demurrer to the complaint in the suit of Thomas A. Edison against Ezra T. Gilliland and John C. Tomlinson.  Edison alleged that he authorized Gilliland to sell his phonograph company stock; that Gilliland found a purchaser -- Mr. Lippincott of Philadelphia; that a contract was made for the sale, and that then he made a discovery.  It was that Gilliland, having taken Tomlinson in with him, had agreed with Mr. Lippincott to take the stock for $500,000 and to pay $250,000 for certain rights to sell phonographs held by Gilliland.  Gilliland, Edison charges, represented that he was to be paid for his agency rights in stock not worth over $75,000, and at the same tie had an agreement with Lippincott to take the stock off his hands at par.  Mr. Edison sued to recover the $250,000, which he alleged the defendants had obtained by fraud.  

Judge Wallace says:  

'The bill is fatally defective.  Because the facts set forth do not disclose that the plaintiff has parted with his stock or otherwise been a loser in consequence of the alleged misconduct of the defendants.  He has entered into an agreement to sell and deliver his stock at a future day upon receiving the purchase money, but that day had long expired before the bill was filed, and it does not appear that the contract was ever consummated.  For all that appears he has the stock now, is still its owner, and nothering ever came from the contract.  Whether Lippincott repudiated it or whether the plaintiff did or whether it was carried out is left wholly to conjecture.

'It must be assumed upon demurrer that the plaintiff has stated his case as favorably as the facts will permit.  It must be inferred therefore that the contract for some unexplained reason has fallen through and that the plaintiff is in the same position as before it was made.  The case as stated by the bill is at best one in which a principal has employed agents to sell property for him and they have taken advantage of their agency to sell their own property at a price largely in excess of its real value.  The case is not one where the principal has lost the sale of his own property by the misconduct of his agents, but the theory of the bill is tht the property was actually sold, while the facts alleged show that the sale has never been completed, and consequently that the plaintiff has lost nothing by the transaction.'"

Source:  AGAINST EDISON -- THE WIZARD'S SUIT AGAINST GILLILAND AND TOMLINSON DECIDED, N.Y. Times, Apr. 11, 1890.  


Labels: , , , , , , , ,